Networked Journalism Education

An experiment in journalism education from France

with one comment

Le Monde has announced its own educational program designed to expand the diversity of its journalists. Rather than hiring from the ranks of college graduates trained in journalism, the respected daily newspaper is sponsoring a competition to select 68 aspiring journalists from many different backgrounds, who will then be mentored by Le Monde journalists:

France’s Le Monde launches plan to lure fresh talent- and readers- into the fold
…Le Monde Academie, launched Wednesday, is a two-part competition and training programme that will offer 68 aspiring journalists from diverse backgrounds the opportunity to be mentored by the newspaper’s staff and published within its pages. It will culminate a year from now, with three ambitious young talents receiving a rare prize: jobs within one of France’s best-respected media companies. ….With the Monde academie, the 68-year-old daily is seeking new voices from diverse socio-economic and cultural backgrounds, which will attract new eyes to a publication that has traditionally been written by and for an educated elite. (Editors Weblog)

This approach made me think of the findings of a Betty Medsger study that showed prize-winning journalists tended to come from disciplines besides journalism. Medsger found:

  • 59 percent of print journalists who won Pulitzer Prizes never studied journalism;
  • 75 percent of broadcast journalists who won DuPont Awards never studied journalism;
  • 58 percent of journalists awarded Nieman Fellowships never studied journalism, and;
  • 51 percent of journalists awarded Knight Fellowships at Stanford University never studied journalism.

(From Getting Journalism Education Out of the Way by Betty Medsger.)

Le Monde is not making itself into a teaching hospital; it is mentoring promising journalists who bring with them a variety of experiences and perspectives. By attracting the best talent from across all disciplines, rather than the most educated from within journalism, they are betting that their work will become stronger and more inclusive.

If half of all practicing doctors never studied medicine, then it would make more sense to model journalism education after medical education (read Eric Newton’s recent argument for this approach and the article Shaping 21st Century Journalism). The current state of American journalism suggests that trying to make journalism a professional field from the ranks of undergraduates has some built-in limitations.

Perhaps our efforts should be spent on creating educational programs that attract the smartest, most creative and passionate storytellers, programmers and community-minded citizens we can find. Perhaps the curriculum of the Le Monde newsroom is exactly what would excite a group of people who might never sign up for an undergraduate curriculum that focuses on newswriting and technology.

Right now, accredited journalism schools teach a curriculum shaped in large part by the professionals who serve on The Accrediting Council on Education in Journalism and Mass Communications. Instead, what if we developed a curriculum designed to attract the brightest and most creative students to journalism? How might journalism be changed by changing the students who study it?

Written by Donica

June 11th, 2012 at 4:43 am

One Response to 'An experiment in journalism education from France'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'An experiment in journalism education from France'.

  1. [...] on studentdev.jour.unr.edu Share this:ShareTwitterEmailPrintDiggFacebookLinkedInRedditStumbleUponTumblrLike this:LikeBe the [...]

Leave a Reply